Employment: government performance – Matters of Public Importance Speech delivered in Parliament 14 March 2012
Mr PALLAS (Tarneit) — I rise to support the matter of public importance put forward by the member for Mulgrave, the Leader of the Opposition. In so doing I want to rely on comments made in this place previously. On 19 September 2001, the following comments were made:
- This government has provided no vision, there has been no action and there have been no results … You can cover your arse, Premier, but eventually you are going to take — —
The DEPUTY SPEAKER — Order! That is unparliamentary language.
I ask the member to rephrase.
Mr PALLAS— I am just quoting what the current Premier of the state said in this place.
The DEPUTY SPEAKER — Order! I am sorry; I did not realise the member was quoting.
Mr PALLAS— I am relying on Hansard. Once again:
- This government has provided no vision, there has been no action and there have been no results … You can cover your arse, Premier, but eventually you are going to take a bath, because you have done nothing!
- … What this government has not done is extraordinary.
- How can one Premier do so much nothing?
As I said, that was said on 19 September 2001. It appears at page 403 of Hansard. You could not imagine a person more qualified to talk about sloth and inaction than the current Premier of this state. Nor could you identify a better demonstration of failure than by simply looking at what the statistics tell us about jobs in this state. Victoria has become the employment drain of the nation.
Honourable members interjecting.
Mr PALLAS— It would be sad if those opposite considered that by simply raising the nature of the problem you are doing a disservice to this state. The greatest disservice that can be done to this state is to pretend that the problem does not exist.
Victoria has become the employment drain of the nation, shedding more than 1000 jobs a week since the middle of last year. I am not surprised that those opposite do not want to talk about jobs. They did not mention the issue in their budget, and it has not been an issue of substance until, faced with the blistering reality that this is a crisis of monumental proportions, they have had to act.
Victoria shed 27 700 jobs in the six months to the end of February. Victoria has lost more than 10 times the number of jobs lost by New South Wales over the past six months, when some 2200 jobs were lost in that state. Since April 2011, Victoria has lost 42 000 full-time jobs. To put that in context, 1 in every 50 jobs in the Victorian labour force has been lost. That is a demonstration of this government’s failure to even acknowledge that there is a problem. Let us not forget that members came into this chamber to debate what is front and centre — a crisis in jobs in this state — and the government did not even want to debate the issue.
We now know that on this issue Victoria is facing a grave situation. Over the past 12 months, 60 000 Victorians simply gave up looking for work. If we translated that loss in the active size of the labour market — that is, translated that participation rate into a real jobless rate — the unemployment rate would be 6.7 per cent. If we simply put the people who gave up looking for work straight back into the labour force, that is where we would be: with 6.7 per cent unemployment. We have a failure to acknowledge what is a substantial and growing problem.
Let us compare it to where we were in 2009 and 2010 — and let us not forget that back then those opposite came into this place and talked about a crisis in jobs.
That crisis in jobs was 200 000 jobs created between 2009 and 2010; and 92 per cent of all the full-time jobs created in Australia in 2010 were created in this state. If that constituted an issue of concern for the then members of the opposition, now the government — the people who consider it un-Victorian to raise these issues as matters of consequence and substance to occupy this chamber’s interest — I am not like them.
I think the issue of jobs is, as the Leader of the Opposition quite appropriately stated, an issue that goes to people’s very sense of worth, it goes to their appreciation of their circumstances, it goes to their security, to their purpose, to their dignity and to their overall sense of wellbeing. If the government is not interested in jobs, then it has given up on the aspirations of ordinary Victorians, and that is an indictment upon it.
Almost 50 000 full-time jobs have disappeared in Victoria over the last 12 months, with effectively only 14 000 part-time jobs created. Let us not forget that 12 600 jobs were lost across the state last month at a rate of 434 per day. Of the 2.848 million Victorians in work, there are now less people in work than when this government came to government. If we combined the level of unemployment and the level of underemployment into a single database, we would have a figure of 12.7 per cent of the workforce effectively unemployed or underemployed — that is, looking for more work. That constitutes something like one in eight Victorians who want more work, and whose fault is that?
We will hear from the Treasurer that it is because of the carbon tax and it is everybody else’s fault. This is a government that aspires to blame everybody else for the challenges it confronts. We know the truth behind that. This is a government that has failed to inspire or indeed even attend to the day-to-day issues.
Who could forget its job-destroying ports tax — a 15 per cent increase in costs for every exporter in this state. Why is it, Treasurer, that exports dropped? They dropped last month in trade weighted value by almost 30 per cent. Take your responsibility for the things that you — —
The DEPUTY SPEAKER — Order! The member for Tarneit, through the Chair.
Mr PALLAS — I beg your pardon, Deputy Speaker. This is a government that refuses to take responsibility for its failings and its omissions. Let us not forget that this is a government that has effectively said, ‘We will take $75 million out of the pockets of Victorians — exporters and importers — on the basis that it will pay for our vision’. What is that vision? We heard from the Premier yesterday when he listed three projects and three projects only. Those projects were Labor projects, so we are funding Labor’s vision.
Whatever failings and shortcomings may have occurred under the previous government, we have to acknowledge that as humans we all make mistakes, but let us not forget the greatest sin of them all, the sin of omission from a fiscally flatulent, feckless bunch of phoneys.
As Francis Bacon once said:
- There is no comparison between that which is lost by not succeeding and that which is lost by not trying.
And this government fails even to try. It cannot even mount a credible argument about what its long-term vision is. Its vision is nothing short of a potpourri of stolen ideas and feckless and useless excuses about why it is not to blame for the failings that are confronting the state, the failings that are directly attributable to this government.
Remember that this is a government that promised — with a great big ‘policy implemented’ blue stamp all over it — 1000 jobs for the people of Geelong for a feasibility study in the relocation of vehicle trade. I am waiting for that because the shipping industry says that will kill it, the vehicle industry says that will kill it, and the government went around making promises to the people of Geelong. This was a failed project before it even got started, because this is a government of thought bubbles and major projects zeros. You have done nothing, you will fail at nothing because you do nothing — —
The DEPUTY SPEAKER — Order! The member for Tarneit, through the Chair.
Mr PALLAS — It will do nothing but sit around waiting for this government to have a vision and a direction, to make an investment, to demonstrate some faith in jobs in this state by growing the state. The construction industry needs it, jobs are at a crisis point, and the government needs to act.